My Butyl Heart

Log Type: 
Maintenance Log

It seemed so easy. There were only two things that we had to do and we had two days to do them. I was harboring a secret wish to finish them all on the first day and then sail, to the point where we actually brought all of the sailing necessities, but man, I can't get this maintenance monkey off my back.

Saturday

We got down to the shore late, which is kind of the cornerstone of our relationship with the shore. I specifically got up early to get to the store and pick up a few last minute things, but that turned into a two hour [Jen: it was more like two and a half] expedition involving multiple stores and the depletion of my remaining West Marine credit. 

The only two things that we needed to do were to replace the stanchions and put in a depth sounder.

Ok, so there were multiple steps to each of these.

First of all, it's important to injure yourself early: I removed a 2 inch patch of skin from my forearm while getting into the boat, because it was unlikely that I'd be leaning on that all day as I crawled around the interior of a boat that doesn't have standing headroom for most second graders.

Before we could put the new stanchions on, we had to get the old bases off. The old posts broke off at the welds (which I suppose is preferable to having them pull through the deck), leaving the bases intact. For each stanchion, there were two nuts that I could turn from the inside and two that Jen had to turn from the outside because the nuts on the outboard side are so close to the hull that you can't fit a socket around them. I mentioned this briefly (and included a crude diagram) in the last log entry. That was actually based on having only looked at one of the stanchions from the inside...not realizing that every one is completely unique. Some of them were even worse, with half of the nut tucked somehow up under the hull:

Captured Nut

For those, the only thing I could do was put an open-ended wrench on them and have Jen unscrew them from the deck, because there was no room to do anything with them from below. Getting them out, however, was still easier than putting the new ones in.

I've been a little gun shy about posting on the sailing forums. I only ever really posted on one and it got a little slow and predictable and between that and possibly my own hubris, I went about these projects without consulting anyone who knows anything about boats, for better or worse. My take was that we shouldn't mess around with something like lifelines (I mean, they're literally called lifelines) and stanchions, so I bought brand new ones. It's possible that I could have fixed my old ones or found used ones on some donor boat somewhere or just gotten rid of them completely, but I felt like I was doing the conscientious thing. I now wonder if this is this same kind of faulty logic that makes people take their cars to the dealership for non-warranty work.

The new stanchions didn't quite fit. The holes were slightly off, which made them slightly (100%, give or take) incompatible out of the box. Bring on the torrent of profanity. The next steps were:

  • Drive to West Marine again
  • Spend $40 on an epoxy kit that I already have at home to save $20 in gas plus 2 hours of driving
  • Tape up the bottoms of the holes
  • Mix colloidal silica in with epoxy to give it some gap-filling properties
  • Desperately make tools out of reeds to force the epoxy into the holes, like some kind of lesser primate making a termite-getting stick
  • Forget the idea of completing the lifelines/stanchions today

On the depth finder front, I did get the display mounted. After the absolute fiasco of expanding the hole for the compass with a drill-mounted grinding stone, I was all proud of myself for having the right size hole saw—until I realized that the back needed a slightly larger hole. You can't increase the size of a hole by using a hole saw because there's nothing for the central bit to bite into, so I was back to the grinder. Tensions were high.

 

Sunday

Against all logic, Jen went back to the shore with me on Sunday for a double-dose of excitement. The epoxy cured well, and my fair lady helped me scrape and sand the areas flat so that we'd have a nicely faired area to re-bed the stanchions. I went about re-drilling appropriately-spaced holes and countersinking them while Jen washed the deck to maximize our chances of success with the butyl tape.

Butyled Stanchion

Just as with the base removal process, I was inside and Jen was outside. She's not quite tall enough to comfortably reach the toerail while standing on the ground, but our decks aren't wide enough to give her room to sit on the deck, so she had to just uncomfortably work from the ground or standing on the trailer. It was a huge pain for both of us, with me working blindly, contorted, laying on my back and pushing nuts into tiny cracks of jagged fiberglass hoping to get them threaded as Jen turned them. She isn't exactly used to operating a ratchet, but was doing just that, over her head for hours. She cleaned the excess butyl as it oozed out, and made me this butyl heart:

Butyl Heart

Pay no attention to how ridiculously filthy the cockpit is, or to the bolt that I somehow sheared off cleanly with the little baby 1/4" drive ratchet (I gave Jen the 3/8 to give her maximum torque).  

Jen literally went to take a nap while I tried to figure out how to add our depthfinder and compass light to our electrical panel. I don't even want to talk about it, but it technically works, as does our VFH, AM/FM radio, and cabin lights. I'll hope that the rest of the lights work at least as poorly as they did before I started pulling out wire nuts in a blind rage. 

By the time I got done crimping and heat shrinking and throwing together impromptu bus bars made out of leftover stanchion bolts, we figured that it was too late to launch the boat, which we would have had to do to test and mount the depth finder's sensor. I had been so wrapped up in trying to figure out the electrical system that I forgot that we hadn't actually put up the lifelines. That was probably due in part to the fact that I have no idea how to swage cable.

In reality, that process was pretty simple, even though I was running out of enthusiasm for spinning bolts. The kit came with a cable snipper and crimping tool that's just a die that you put around the fitting and tighten with a wrench or socket. I think it actually came out pretty well, and I was glad to finally get something finished in this seemingly endless maintenance cycle.

Crimps

We're getting there. We wouldn't be half this far if Jen hadn't helped both days, and I'm incredibly thankful that she's not the kind of sailing wife who just wants to use the boat as a mobile sun deck, or worse: resents the boat. While her love for the boat might be a tad healthier than mine, it's definitely something we share.

I'm bringing the sails next week, and hopefully I can stop whining about maintenance and resume tales of sailing adventure on the low seas.

Lifelines On

 

 

 

 

Nice to see work is getting

Nice to see work is getting done and that someone else has about the same luck working on their boat as I do. :-) Good luck with the rest and hope you have a great season!

Thanks Dan, and best of luck

Thanks Dan, and best of luck with Papillon.

Been there, done that! I know

Been there, done that!

I know it's a compact boat, but if you can fit aluminum 1/4 inch backing plates on even two of the four bolts to spread the load, you will reduce the flex on the bases which will in turn increase the chances of leaks and decrease the chances something will snap if a crew is thrown on it.

I realize unbolting, custom cutting alu plate and trading in for bolts 1/2 inch longer is probably not a priority, but maybe next fall? I cut and installed backing plates under most of my deck gear on the FG 33 footer after I actually tore my port genoa track out of the deck in 28 knots...and I haven't regretted it: the boat is officially "better than factory" and certainly better than the compressed core and dished fender washers that the backing plates replaced. Metal Supermarket is your friend.

Thanks Marc. Of course you're

Thanks Marc. Of course you're right, and adding backing plates was the first thing I thought of when I started this. I just couldn't believe how inaccessible everything was. Maybe some weird warm weekend over the winter...

Chip, It doesn't get any

Chip,
It doesn't get any better with a bigger boat, in fact you just have more to do.
The good news is you bled before the start of any projects - I find that if you don't bleed it's not done.

I'm sure there's more to do

I'm sure there's more to do on a larger boat, but I'm confident that my ability to complain about it will expand with the scale of the tasks.  

Great read. Hope you get out

Great read. Hope you get out soon. You guys really amaze me at you dedication. I remember that first day we met in Baltimore to look at buying Fortuitous. You seem as exited, even more now.

Hope to see you and Jen soontis summer.

Dave

Thanks Dave, hope to see you

Thanks Dave, hope to see you too. We're kind of still acting like a couple dumb kids with a new boat, but I'm ok with that.